Direct response advertising agency

Move Over Meteor: Derby Is The Other High Speed Node.js Framework In Town


Although the company behind Meteor, a framework for building real-time JavaScript applications in vein of Google Docs, just announced a nice big $11.2 million round of funding, itÔÇÖs not the only game in town. In my story earlier this week I mentioned Mojito, a framework developed by Yahoo. But thereÔÇÖs still another framework that has escaped my attention, even though itÔÇÖs around longer than Meteor: Derby.

Much like Meteor and Mojito, Derby is a client and server side JavaScript framework for building real-time applications. Its synchronization engine Racer can be used independent of Derby.

Nate Smith (an ex-Googler) and Brian Noguchi are the core developers of the framework, and the founders of the stealth startup Lever. ÔÇ£We have a stable financial base,ÔÇØ Smith wrote on the projectÔÇÖs Google Group. ÔÇ£We have a very different business model than Meteor, and we are creating a product-focused company that will continue to support the framework.ÔÇØ Meteor, on the other hand, is being developed as the primary product of the Meteor Development Group.

From a technical standpoint, one major difference is the way the projects handle server side JavaScript. Both projects use Node.js on the server side, but Meteor uses a library called Fibers that fundamentally changes the way Node.js applications are written. By default, Node.js uses callbacks, an approach to coding thatÔÇÖs well explained for non-programmers here. Fibers abstract callbacks away so that developers can use a more traditional style of programming. Fibers vs. callbacks has become a contentious argument in the Node.js community. Proponents of using Fibers instead of callbacks claim itÔÇÖs much easier to code in Node.js using Fibers. The core Node.js team claims that only a vocal minority of the community prefer Fibers. Even if thatÔÇÖs the case, it could be that developers who donÔÇÖt like callbacks are simply being scared away from Node. On the other hand, IÔÇÖm told that the fact that the callback model was essential to Node.jsÔÇÖ success. There have been many attempts to run JavaScript on servers since the languages introduction in 1995, but Node.js is the first one to really take off. Many of the failed server side JavaScript projects tried to shoehorn JavaScript into more traditional programming approaches, but Node.js embraced the asynchronous nature of JavaScript.

It could be that thereÔÇÖs room for both approaches. Tim Caswell, the resident Node.js mentor at Cloud9 IDE, concluded ÔÇ£Instead of teaching newcomers to never use these tools, I simply advise them to learn the basics first and then once they are comfortable with that feel free to experiment with these alternative tools.ÔÇØ

Anyway, itÔÇÖs not a zero sum game, but one thing that will determine the success of these projects is community adoption. As Matt Asay points out, you canÔÇÖt buy a community with VC cash. ItÔÇÖs early days for both communities. Meteor has a few more contributors than Derby but both projects have attracted a few contributors from outside the sponsor companies. Both have small but active mailing lists.




End of panel-container –>

You May Also Like

protective packaging

The Purpose of Protective Packaging

protective packaging

3 Ways Your Products Can Be Damaged In Transit

desiccant packs

Top 5 Benefits of Desiccant Packs

real estate lawyer in NYC

What To Do When Your Roommate Won’t Pay Rent